Frage 1
Passage III — Humanities: “The Reader Cannot Check” (original essay written for this practice set)
The oldest rule of travel writing is that the reader cannot check. A traveler who returns from a distant country may describe anything—mountains of salt, rivers of milk, a king who eats only once a year—and the people at home have little choice but to believe, or to disbelieve, according to taste. For most of history, travel writers have taken full advantage of this rule, and readers have loved them for it.
Consider the most famous travel book of the Middle Ages, the account of the Venetian merchant Marco Polo. Polo did not write it himself. In 1298, while a prisoner of war in Genoa, he dictated his memories to a fellow prisoner named Rustichello, a writer of romances about knights and enchanted castles. The result is a curious blend. Alongside careful descriptions of paper money, of black stones burned for fuel, and of a vast system of relay stations for official messengers, all of which later travelers confirmed, there are passages that read like Rustichello’s other books, full of battles told in the same phrases he used for King Arthur’s. Scholars have argued for centuries over which parts belong to the merchant and which to the romancer. The book was enormously popular, and almost no one in its own time could tell the difference.
A few decades later, an even more popular book appeared under the name of Sir John Mandeville, an English knight who claimed to have traveled through Egypt, India, and China. His readers learned of men with the heads of dogs, of a plant that grew lambs instead of fruit, and of a fountain whose water kept the drinker young. Most modern historians doubt that “Mandeville” ever existed; the book appears to have been assembled from other people’s accounts by someone who may never have left Europe. Yet it was translated into a dozen languages, and Christopher Columbus is said to have studied it before he sailed.
It would be comforting to think that we have outgrown such books. We have not. Today’s travel writing, much of it published on social media, has merely exchanged one kind of invention for another. The dog-headed men are gone, but in their place we find the empty beach photographed at dawn so that the crowds are cropped out, the “hidden” café that has appeared in a hundred other posts, and the local who seems to exist only to say something wise to the visitor. The modern traveler rarely lies outright, and she would be offended to be compared with Mandeville. She simply chooses, as Rustichello did, the details that make a better story.
I do not mean to condemn travel writers, old or new. A travel account is always a story about a place, not the place itself, and every story requires selection. The trouble begins when the writer pretends otherwise—when the selection is presented as the whole truth. The travel books I value most are those in which the author admits, sometimes directly and sometimes only through a tone of humility, how little a visitor can see. A writer who spends three days in a city and describes its “soul” is claiming more than any visitor can honestly know, however sincere the claim may be. A writer who describes the three days, and the noise of the street outside the hotel, and the waiter who corrected her pronunciation, is offering something smaller but sturdier.
Years ago I spent a week in a mountain village in Peru and returned home full of confident opinions about the people who lived there. When I described the village to a friend who had grown up nearby, she listened politely and then said, “That sounds like a nice place. I’m not sure it’s the one I know.” I have tried to remember her answer every time I have written about a place since. It is the most useful sentence about travel writing I have ever heard, and it was never written down.
Which detail from the passage best supports the idea that parts of Marco Polo’s book were accurate?
- A. Its descriptions of paper money and relay stations for messengers were confirmed by later travelers.
- B. It was enormously popular in its own time.
- C. It was dictated while Polo was a prisoner of war in Genoa.
- D. Its battle scenes used the same phrases as stories about King Arthur.
Antwort und Erklärung anzeigen
Richtige Antwort: A. Its descriptions of paper money and relay stations for messengers were confirmed by later travelers.
Erklärung
The passage says that the descriptions of paper money, fuel stones, and relay stations were all things “which later travelers confirmed,” which is direct evidence of accuracy.
Popularity is not proof of accuracy, the circumstances of dictation say nothing about truth, and the borrowed battle phrases suggest invention.