Compare the structure (all, some, none, if… then), not the topic.
Strategie Schritt für Schritt
Reduce the argument to letters and check conclusion, premises and validity.
Typische Fallen
Choosing a valid argument with another form, or one with a different flaw.
Beispielfragen
Versuche zu antworten, bevor du die Lösung öffnest. Die Fragen sind in der Prüfungssprache.
Frage 1
Schwierigkeit: schwer≈ 1 min
Any restaurant that earns a star in the regional guide must pass an annual health inspection. Cedar House did not pass this year's inspection. Therefore, Cedar House will not earn a star in the guide.
The pattern of reasoning in which one of the following arguments is most similar to that in the argument above?
AA. Every driver who is awarded a license must pass a road test. Kofi passed his road test. Therefore, Kofi will be awarded a license.
BB. Every driver who is awarded a license must pass a road test. Kofi was not awarded a license. Therefore, Kofi did not pass the road test.
CC. Anyone who is awarded a scholarship must submit an essay. Dara did not submit an essay. Therefore, Dara will not be awarded a scholarship.
DD. Some students who submit an essay are awarded a scholarship. Dara submitted an essay. Therefore, Dara will probably be awarded a scholarship.
EE. Anyone who is awarded a scholarship must submit an essay. Dara will be awarded a scholarship. Therefore, Dara submitted an essay.
Antwort und Erklärung anzeigen
Richtige Antwort: C. Anyone who is awarded a scholarship must submit an essay. Dara did not submit an essay. Therefore, Dara will not be awarded a scholarship.
Erklärung
The argument has the form: if A then B; not B; therefore not A. Only the scholarship argument about an essay that was not submitted repeats this form. The first two commit the fallacies of affirming the consequent and denying the antecedent, the fourth turns a 'some' statement into a probable conclusion, and the last is a valid argument but moves from A to B rather than from not B to not A.
Frage 2
Schwierigkeit: schwer≈ 2 min
Every successful bakery in the district uses locally milled flour. The Corner Oven uses locally milled flour. So the Corner Oven must be a successful bakery.
The flawed pattern of reasoning in which one of the following arguments is most similar to that in the argument above?
AA. Every cake that wins the fair's blue ribbon contains fresh butter. Meera's cake contains fresh butter. Therefore, Meera's cake will win the blue ribbon.
BB. Every cake that wins the fair's blue ribbon contains fresh butter. Meera's cake will not win the blue ribbon. Therefore, Meera's cake does not contain fresh butter.
CC. Few cakes entered in the fair contain fresh butter. Meera's cake is entered in the fair. Therefore, Meera's cake probably does not contain fresh butter.
DD. Every cake that wins the fair's blue ribbon contains fresh butter. Meera's cake will win the blue ribbon. Therefore, Meera's cake contains fresh butter.
EE. Meera's cake contains fresh butter, and cakes that contain fresh butter taste rich. So Meera's cake tastes rich.
Antwort und Erklärung anzeigen
Richtige Antwort: A. Every cake that wins the fair's blue ribbon contains fresh butter. Meera's cake contains fresh butter. Therefore, Meera's cake will win the blue ribbon.
Erklärung
The flawed form is: all A are B; x is B; so x is A (a property shared by all members of a group is taken to show that an item with the property belongs to the group). The first cake argument has exactly this form. The second denies the antecedent instead, the third is a statistical argument, and the fourth and fifth are valid.
Frage 3
Schwierigkeit: schwer≈ 1 min
If the museum extends its opening hours, it will need more guards. If it needs more guards, its staff budget will rise. The museum's staff budget will not rise. So the museum will not extend its opening hours.
Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its reasoning to the argument above?
AA. If Lena joins the choir, she will rehearse on Thursdays. If she rehearses on Thursdays, she will miss her chess club. Lena will not join the choir. So she will not miss her chess club.
BB. If Lena joins the choir, she will rehearse on Thursdays. If she rehearses on Thursdays, she will miss her chess club. Lena will miss her chess club. So she will join the choir.
CC. If Lena joins the choir, she will rehearse on Thursdays. She will not rehearse on Thursdays unless she misses her chess club. So if Lena joins the choir, she will miss her chess club.
DD. Lena will join the choir only if she rehearses on Thursdays. Lena will rehearse on Thursdays, since her teacher has asked her to. So Lena will join the choir this season.
EE. If Lena joins the choir, she will rehearse on Thursdays. If she rehearses on Thursdays, she will miss her chess club. Lena will not miss her chess club. So she will not join the choir.
Antwort und Erklärung anzeigen
Richtige Antwort: E. If Lena joins the choir, she will rehearse on Thursdays. If she rehearses on Thursdays, she will miss her chess club. Lena will not miss her chess club. So she will not join the choir.
Erklärung
The argument chains two conditionals (A → B → C) and then uses the denial of the last term to deny the first (not C, so not A). Only the answer has that form. The others deny the antecedent, affirm the consequent, draw a chained conditional instead of a denial, or affirm a necessary condition.