examARnow Guides

LSAT · Reading Comprehension · Question types

Author's attitude

The author's tone and stance.

LSAT (Law School Admission Test)Reading ComprehensionWeight: 100 %
Practise Author's attitude for free10 original questions for this skill, marked instantly.

Key points

Step-by-step strategy

Common traps

Sample questions

Try to answer before opening the solution.

Question 1

Difficulty: easy≈ 1 min

Urban agriculture

Advocates of urban farming often claim that vegetables grown on rooftops and in vacant lots cut food miles and strengthen local food security. These claims are plausible but incomplete. The energy saved by shorter transport can be small compared with the energy used in producing food, and a greenhouse heated through the winter can emit more carbon per kilogram of lettuce than a field farm hundreds of kilometers away.

Urban farms offer other benefits that are easier to defend: fresh produce in neighborhoods with few grocery stores, green space that cools the surrounding air, and opportunities for education. The difficulty is that advocates often bundle all these benefits together and then judge urban farming by the weakest of them.

A more honest case would treat each benefit separately, measure it, and ask what the farm costs per unit of benefit. Some farms would still look attractive; others would not.

The author's attitude toward urban farming is best described as

  1. A. firm opposition based on its carbon emissions
  2. B. unqualified enthusiasm for its many benefits
  3. C. qualified support that calls for more rigorous evaluation
  4. D. detached neutrality toward its advocates' claims
  5. E. reluctant acceptance of its environmental costs
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: C. qualified support that calls for more rigorous evaluation

Explanation

The author finds the claims plausible but incomplete and expects some farms to look attractive.

Question 2

Difficulty: medium≈ 2 min

Seaweed and the carbon cycle

Seaweed farming has been proposed as a way to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere: seaweed absorbs carbon as it grows, and if it is then sunk to the deep ocean the carbon could be stored for centuries. Some enthusiasts imagine farms covering vast stretches of ocean.

The proposal faces several difficulties. Much of the carbon in seaweed is released again when the seaweed decays before reaching the seabed, so the stored fraction is uncertain. Large farms might also alter local ecosystems, shading the water and consuming nutrients that other organisms need. The effects of sinking enormous amounts of organic matter on deep-sea life are unknown.

None of this shows that the idea should be dropped. It shows that its benefits have been estimated optimistically and its risks hardly at all, and that pilot projects with careful monitoring should precede any large-scale deployment.

The author's attitude toward the proposal is best described as

  1. A. enthusiastic: expecting it to succeed at a large scale
  2. B. fearful: expecting it to damage life in the deep sea
  3. C. cautiously open: not dismissing it but demanding evidence
  4. D. indifferent: taking no position on whether to pursue it
  5. E. dismissive: regarding the idea as not worth testing
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: C. cautiously open: not dismissing it but demanding evidence

Explanation

'None of this shows that the idea should be dropped', but pilots should come first.

Question 3

Difficulty: hard≈ 2 min

How should a translation be judged?

Translators have long argued over whether a translation should stay close to the wording of the original or should instead reproduce its effect on readers. Advocates of literal translation hold that a text's particular words are part of what it says, so that replacing one idiom with another distorts the author's meaning. They point to philosophical and legal texts, where a shift in a single term can alter an argument or a ruling. Advocates of free translation reply that fidelity to words is often an illusion: a phrase that is plain in one language may sound stilted or even comical in another, so a word-for-word rendering can betray the very tone the author worked to achieve.

A third view, which has gained ground among scholars in recent decades, rejects an assumption shared by both camps, namely that a single correct balance between wording and effect exists for all texts. On this view, what a translator owes readers depends on the function of the text. A user manual must be followed without confusion, so clarity outweighs the preservation of the original's phrasing. A poem, by contrast, is valued in part for its sounds and images, so a translator may sacrifice exact meaning to keep them. Critics of the functional view complain that it makes translation seem like a set of unrelated crafts, and that it gives translators too much license to decide for themselves what a text's function is.

Defenders reply that the license is narrower than it looks. A translator's decision about function is not made in isolation: publishers' briefs, the expectations of readers, and the text's own genre all constrain it, and a translator who ignores these constraints will be judged to have failed. More importantly, they argue, the functional view does not abandon the idea of fidelity; it relocates it. Fidelity becomes a matter of being faithful to what the text is for, rather than to its surface features, and this explains why a translation that would be admired in one setting can rightly be rejected in another.

Which one of the following best describes the author's attitude toward the functional view of translation?

  1. A. enthusiastic endorsement
  2. B. scornful dismissal
  3. C. reporting the view, the criticisms of it and the replies to them without clearly taking a side
  4. D. reluctant acceptance of it as the only workable view
  5. E. indifference to whether it is correct
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: C. reporting the view, the criticisms of it and the replies to them without clearly taking a side

Explanation

The author describes how the view has gained ground, states the critics' complaints and records the defenders' replies, but never says which side is right. No evaluative language such as praise or scorn is used, and the careful, even-handed description is not indifference.

Keep practising

Practise Author's attitude for free10 original questions for this skill, marked instantly.

Other Reading Comprehension skills

Full LSAT format · All guides