A 100+ word post in a forum with a professor's question and two classmates' posts.
Key points
State your opinion clearly in the first sentence.
Add a NEW idea; don't repeat what your classmates said.
Step-by-step strategy
1-minute plan: opinion → new reason → example → closing.
Refer to a classmate: "Tomás is right that…, but…".
Aim for 120–150 words.
Common traps
Summarizing both posts without taking a side.
General statements with no specific example.
Worked example
"I agree with Lina, but for a reason neither classmate mentioned: …"
Sample questions
Try to answer before opening the solution.
Question 1
Difficulty: easy≈ 10 min
Professor
When preparing for an important exam, some students prefer to study in a group, while others prefer to study alone. Which approach do you think is more effective for learning, and why?
Lucas
Studying in a group is better. When I explain an idea to my classmates, I find out quickly whether I really understand it. Also, other people can explain things that I missed in class.
Mei
I prefer studying alone. Groups often get distracted, and we end up talking about other things. When I'm alone, I can focus on the topics I find difficult instead of the ones everyone else wants to review.
Your professor is teaching a class on psychology. Read the professor's question and your classmates' posts. Then write a post that states and supports your own opinion and adds something new to the discussion. Write at least 100 words. You have 10 minutes.
100–200 words · 10 min.
Show model answer and criteria
Model answer
In my opinion, the most effective approach is to study alone first and then meet with a group near the end. Mei is right that groups waste time when the members are not prepared, but Lucas makes a good point about explaining ideas to others. If everyone studies alone first, the group meeting can be used only for difficult questions and for testing each other. Last semester, I tried this for my biology final. I spent a week reviewing on my own, and then three classmates and I met for two hours to quiz each other. Because we were all prepared, nobody got distracted, and I discovered two topics I had misunderstood. My grade was the best I have ever had in a science class.
Marking criteria
States a clear opinion that answers the professor's question
Supports the opinion with reasons, explanations, and at least one specific example
Adds a new idea instead of only repeating the two students' points
Coherent flow with clear connections between ideas
Wide, accurate range of vocabulary and grammar
Explanation
Choosing a combination is allowed if the position is clear. The sample states a specific approach (alone first, then a group), connects it to both classmates' points, and adds a new idea with a concrete personal example and a result. A response that only says "I agree with Lucas" and repeats his reason would not add enough to the discussion.
Question 2
Difficulty: medium≈ 10 min
Professor
Our topic today is the move from secondary school to higher education. In some countries, it is common for students to take a “gap year”: a year off between finishing school and starting university, spent working, traveling, or volunteering. Would you recommend a gap year to most students? Explain your view.
Aisha
I think it’s a great idea. After twelve years of school, many students are tired. A year of working or volunteering helps them mature and arrive at university knowing what they really want to study.
Tom
I’m not convinced. Once students stop studying, it can be hard to get back into the habit. Some of my friends planned a gap year and never went to university at all.
Your professor is teaching a class on sociology. Read the professor’s question and your classmates’ posts. Then write a post that states and supports your own opinion and adds something new to the discussion. Write at least 100 words. You have 10 minutes.
100–200 words · 10 min.
Show model answer and criteria
Model answer
I think a gap year is a good idea, but only if students plan it carefully. Tom is right that some people lose the habit of studying, yet I believe the problem is an unplanned year, not the gap year itself. Aisha mentions maturity, and I would add a practical benefit: a year of work lets students save money, so they can borrow less for university. My cousin worked in a bakery for ten months before college, and the savings paid for most of his first-year housing. To avoid Tom’s concern, students could apply to university before the gap year and defer their place. That way, they have a clear date to return and a reason to stay focused.
Marking criteria
States a clear opinion that answers the professor's question
Supports the opinion with reasons, explanations, and at least one specific example
Adds a new idea instead of only repeating the two students' points
Coherent flow with clear connections between ideas
Wide, accurate range of vocabulary and grammar
Explanation
A strong post takes a clear position, responds to both classmates, and adds a new idea (here, saving money and deferring a university place) supported by a specific example. Repeating Aisha’s or Tom’s points without adding anything would not move the discussion forward.
Question 3
Difficulty: hard≈ 10 min
Professor
Over the next two weeks we will discuss how cities fund cultural institutions. Many public museums charge an entrance fee, while others are free to everyone and are paid for entirely by taxes and donations. In your opinion, should public museums be free for all visitors? Why or why not?
Nadia
Yes. Museums hold a shared cultural heritage, so everyone should be able to enjoy it. When there is a fee, families with low incomes are the first to stop going.
Tomás
I don’t agree. Running a museum is very expensive. If visitors pay nothing, the museum depends completely on government budgets, and those can be cut at any time.
Your professor is teaching a class on urban studies. Read the professor’s question and the two posts from your classmates. Then write your own post, giving and supporting your opinion and contributing a new idea to the discussion. Write at least 100 words. You have 10 minutes.
100–200 words · 10 min.
Show model answer and criteria
Model answer
I think a middle path works best: museums should charge most adults but stay free for students and children. Nadia is right that fees keep some families away, and Tomás makes a fair point about unstable budgets. What neither of them mentions is the effect on young people. Visiting museums early in life builds a habit that often lasts. In my city, the art museum became free for anyone under eighteen a few years ago, and now school groups and teenagers go there on weekends, not just tourists. Meanwhile, adult tickets still cover part of the costs, so the museum is not completely dependent on the government. This approach protects access for the visitors who benefit most while keeping the museum financially stable.
Marking criteria
States a clear opinion that answers the professor's question
Supports the opinion with reasons, explanations, and at least one specific example
Adds a new idea instead of only repeating the two students' points
Coherent flow with clear connections between ideas
Wide, accurate range of vocabulary and grammar
Explanation
A strong post takes a clear position (here, a balanced one), acknowledges both classmates, and adds a new idea, such as the long-term value of free access for young people, supported by a specific example. Simply restating that museums are a shared heritage or that they are expensive would not add to the discussion.