Lis d'abord l'affirmation exacte : la preuve doit correspondre à TOUTES ses parties.
Avec des tableaux, le bon choix doit être vrai d'après les données ET pertinent pour l'affirmation.
Méthode pas à pas
Marque les mots clés de l'affirmation (« more than », « especially », « but »).
Vérifie chaque nombre du choix dans le tableau : ligne, colonne et année.
Pièges fréquents
Des données vraies mais sans rapport avec l'affirmation.
Des données de la mauvaise ligne ou colonne, ou une comparaison inversée.
Exemple corrigé
Affirmation : “sales rose especially in winter.” Une preuve utile compare la hausse de l'hiver à celle des autres saisons ; le chiffre de l'hiver seul ne suffit pas.
Exemples de questions
Essayez de répondre avant d'ouvrir le corrigé. Les questions sont dans la langue de l'examen.
Question 1
Difficulté: facile≈ 1 min
In Teresa Malvar’s novel Northbound, the narrator, who grew up on a farm, moves to a large city to work in her cousin’s shop. In the early chapters, Malvar shows that the narrator feels out of place in her new surroundings.
Which quotation from Northbound most effectively illustrates the claim?
AA. “My cousin met me at the station holding a borrowed umbrella.”
BB. “The apartment was on the fourth floor, above a shoe repair shop.”
CC. “The streetlights hummed all night, and I missed the crickets.”
DD. “On Sundays, the bakery downstairs sold its bread at half price.”
Voir la réponse et l'explication
Bonne réponse: C. “The streetlights hummed all night, and I missed the crickets.”
Explication
The claim is that the narrator feels out of place in the city. Hearing the streetlights hum all night and missing the crickets of the farm shows that she is not comfortable in her new home.
The other quotations describe her arrival, where the apartment is, and a bakery’s prices; none reveals how she feels.
Question 2
Difficulté: moyenne≈ 1 min
Cuban poet José Martí wrote Versos sencillos (Simple Verses), published in 1891, while living in exile in New York. In the collection’s opening poem, the speaker presents himself as someone who does not belong to any single place.
Which quotation from the opening poem of Versos sencillos (translated from Spanish) most effectively illustrates the claim?
AA. “I know the strange names / of the grasses and the flowers”
BB. “I cultivate a white rose / in June as in January”
CC. “I come from everywhere, / and toward everywhere I go”
DD. “I want to cast my lot / with the poor of the earth”
Voir la réponse et l'explication
Bonne réponse: C. “I come from everywhere, / and toward everywhere I go”
Explication
The claim is that the speaker does not belong to a single place. Saying “I come from everywhere, / and toward everywhere I go” directly presents him as belonging to all places rather than one.
Knowing the names of plants, growing a white rose, and siding with the poor describe the speaker’s knowledge, generosity, and loyalties, not his relationship to place.
Question 3
Difficulté: difficile≈ 2 min
Archaeologists excavating a 9,000-year-old village in Anatolia found that most houses had no doors at ground level; residents apparently entered through openings in the roofs. One team argues that rooftop entry was mainly a defense against flooding from a nearby river, which overflowed its banks in most springs.
Which finding, if true, would most directly weaken the team’s argument?
AA. Some houses in the village had painted decorations on their interior walls.
BB. Villages built at the same time on hilltops far above any river also used rooftop entry almost exclusively.
CC. Sediment layers show that the river near the village flooded more often than the team had estimated.
DD. Ladders found in the houses were made from wood that grew along the riverbank.
Voir la réponse et l'explication
Bonne réponse: B. Villages built at the same time on hilltops far above any river also used rooftop entry almost exclusively.
Explication
If rooftop entry was mainly a response to flooding, villages that faced no flood risk would have had little reason to use it. Finding that hilltop villages far above any river used rooftop entry almost exclusively suggests some other cause, weakening the argument.
Painted walls are irrelevant. More frequent flooding would, if anything, strengthen the argument. The source of the ladder wood says nothing about why roofs were used as entrances.