Identifie l'affirmation principale de chaque texte avant de regarder les choix.
Le Texte 2 nuance souvent, remet en question ou propose une autre explication.
Méthode pas à pas
Demande-toi : l'auteur 2 est-il d'accord, pas d'accord ou en partie d'accord ?
Trouve la phrase exacte du Texte 2 qui répond au Texte 1.
Pièges fréquents
Réponses extrêmes : « prouve que c'est faux » alors que l'auteur demande seulement plus de preuves.
Attribuer à un texte une idée qui n'apparaît que dans l'autre.
Exemple corrigé
Texte 1 : “video games improve attention.” Texte 2 : “the studies measure only tasks very similar to the games.” → L'auteur 2 dirait que la conclusion dépasse ce que montrent les études.
Exemples de questions
Essayez de répondre avant d'ouvrir le corrigé. Les questions sont dans la langue de l'examen.
Question 1
Difficulté: facile≈ 1 min
Text 1
Ötzi, a man whose frozen body was found in the Alps in 1991, lived about 5,300 years ago. At first, many researchers thought he had simply died of cold and exhaustion after being caught in a snowstorm high in the mountains.
Text 2
In 2001, X-ray images revealed a stone arrowhead lodged in Ötzi’s left shoulder. The arrow had torn a major artery, and he probably bled to death within minutes.
Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to the early view described in Text 1?
AA. By agreeing that Ötzi most likely died of cold and exhaustion
BB. By arguing that Ötzi lived much more recently than 5,300 years ago
CC. By pointing out that Ötzi was most likely killed by an arrow wound
DD. By claiming that Ötzi’s body was actually found outside the Alps
Voir la réponse et l'explication
Bonne réponse: C. By pointing out that Ötzi was most likely killed by an arrow wound
Explication
Text 2 reports an arrowhead that tore an artery, so Ötzi “probably bled to death within minutes.” Its author would reject the early view that he died of cold and point to the arrow wound instead.
Text 2 contradicts the cold-and-exhaustion view rather than agreeing with it, and it does not question Ötzi’s age or where he was found.
Question 2
Difficulté: moyenne≈ 1 min
Text 1
Climate scientist Noor Haddad argues that painting rooftops white is one of the cheapest ways to cool cities. White roofs reflect most sunlight, and her measurements show that a white roof can be twenty degrees Celsius cooler than a dark one on a summer afternoon.
Text 2
Building engineer Petra Novak agrees that white roofs reduce summer cooling costs but notes that in cold climates they also reflect welcome winter sunlight, raising heating bills. The net benefit, she argues, depends on the local climate, and in some northern cities it may be close to zero.
Based on the texts, Novak (Text 2) would most likely say that Haddad’s recommendation ______
AA. applies everywhere, regardless of a city’s climate or latitude.
BB. is sound for hot climates but may offer little net benefit in cold ones.
CC. is based on inaccurate measurements of rooftop temperatures.
DD. would raise cooling costs in summer rather than lowering them.
Voir la réponse et l'explication
Bonne réponse: B. is sound for hot climates but may offer little net benefit in cold ones.
Explication
Novak accepts the summer benefit but adds a winter cost in cold climates, concluding the net benefit depends on climate and may be near zero in the north. So she qualifies Haddad’s recommendation by climate.
She does not dispute the measurements, and she agrees cooling costs fall in summer.
Question 3
Difficulté: difficile≈ 2 min
Text 1
Literary critic Aurelio Vance maintains that the poet Mireille Dastan’s late shift to very short poems reflects a loss of ambition: having written sweeping narrative verse in her youth, she retreated in her sixties to fragments of three or four lines.
Text 2
Scholar Beatriz Lund has examined Dastan’s notebooks from the same decade and found that many of the short published poems were distilled from drafts of fifty lines or more. Dastan, Lund argues, was not writing less but cutting more, and the compression demanded greater effort than the earlier expansiveness had.
Based on the texts, Lund (Text 2) would most likely respond to Vance’s claim by ______
AA. agreeing that Dastan wrote less in her sixties than she had in her youth.
BB. citing the notebooks to show that the short poems came from heavy revision, not diminished ambition.
CC. arguing that the early narrative poems were also short when they were first drafted.
DD. suggesting that Vance has misdated the late poems and that they were actually written in her youth.
Voir la réponse et l'explication
Bonne réponse: B. citing the notebooks to show that the short poems came from heavy revision, not diminished ambition.
Explication
Vance reads brevity as retreat. Lund’s notebooks show long drafts cut down to a few lines, which she presents as more effort, not less. She would counter Vance with that evidence.
She denies that Dastan wrote less, says nothing about the early poems’ length, and does not dispute dating.