Both must take a view on the point, in opposite directions.
Step-by-step strategy
Test each option against both speakers.
Common traps
Something only one speaker addresses.
Sample questions
Try to answer before opening the solution.
Question 1
Difficulty: medium≈ 1 min
Lucia: A study found that people who journal regularly report less stress, so journaling must reduce stress. Marco: It could just as easily be the other way around: people with less stress have the time and calm to journal regularly.
Lucia and Marco disagree about whether
AA. people who journal regularly report less stress
BB. the study's participants were representative of the general population
CC. the correlation found in the study shows that journaling reduces stress
DD. journaling is a pleasant activity
EE. stress can be measured reliably
Show answer and explanation
Correct answer: C. the correlation found in the study shows that journaling reduces stress
Explanation
Both accept that journalers report less stress. Lucia infers that journaling causes the reduction, while Marco proposes the reverse direction of cause. They disagree about what the correlation shows. Representativeness, enjoyment and measurement are not mentioned.
Question 2
Difficulty: medium≈ 1 min
Pilar: The museum should make its Tuesday evening hours permanent. Attendance on those evenings has doubled since they were introduced, so visitors clearly want them. Dev: The doubling is misleading. Most Tuesday evening visitors are people who would otherwise have come at another time that week, so total weekly attendance has not changed.
Pilar and Dev disagree over whether
AA. attendance on Tuesday evenings has doubled
BB. the museum should reduce its hours on other days
CC. the increase in Tuesday evening attendance reflects an increase in the museum's overall attendance
DD. Tuesday evening is the busiest time of the week at the museum
EE. the museum can afford to stay open on Tuesday evenings
Show answer and explanation
Correct answer: C. the increase in Tuesday evening attendance reflects an increase in the museum's overall attendance
Explanation
Pilar reads the doubling as evidence of new demand; Dev accepts the doubling but says it only moves visitors from other times. They therefore disagree about whether the rise reflects greater total attendance. Dev does not dispute the doubling itself, and neither speaker discusses other days, the busiest time or cost.
Question 3
Difficulty: medium≈ 2 min
Ava: The new tax on sugary drinks will substantially reduce consumption. Sugary drinks respond to price changes like any other non-essential good, and higher prices reliably reduce demand for those. Ben: Sugary drinks are habit-forming, so demand for them is far less sensitive to price than demand for typical non-essential goods. The tax will change consumption very little.
Ava and Ben disagree about whether
AA. the tax on sugary drinks will raise revenue for the government
BB. sugary drinks are non-essential goods
CC. demand for sugary drinks is as sensitive to price as demand for typical non-essential goods
DD. habit-forming products should be taxed
EE. consumption of sugary drinks is currently high
Show answer and explanation
Correct answer: C. demand for sugary drinks is as sensitive to price as demand for typical non-essential goods
Explanation
Ava says sugary drinks behave like any non-essential good with respect to price; Ben says they are much less sensitive because they are habit-forming. The sensitivity of demand is the point at issue. Neither addresses revenue or whether such products should be taxed, and Ben does not deny that sugary drinks are non-essential.