To weaken, offer another explanation; to strengthen, rule one out.
Step-by-step strategy
Mark the conclusion and ask what would make it false.
Common traps
Facts that are true but irrelevant.
Sample questions
Try to answer before opening the solution.
Question 1
Difficulty: easy≈ 1 min
Researchers measured sleep in 30 college athletes during the off-season and found an average of 9 hours a night. They conclude that adults in general sleep 9 hours a night.
Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the conclusion?
AA. Athletes in the off-season may have far more free time and different sleep needs than other adults.
BB. A separate study of adults in a wide range of occupations also recorded an average of about 9 hours of sleep a night.
CC. The athletes were measured for two full weeks rather than for a single night.
DD. The researchers who ran the study have published several earlier papers on sleep.
EE. None of the athletes in the study reported taking medication that affects sleep.
Show answer and explanation
Correct answer: B. A separate study of adults in a wide range of occupations also recorded an average of about 9 hours of sleep a night.
Explanation
The answer adds evidence that the result holds beyond the group sampled (a separate study of adults in a wide range of occupations also recorded an average of about 9 hours of sleep a night), which addresses the worry that the sample is unrepresentative without contradicting the information given. The option about how the sample differs from the population would weaken the conclusion, and the others concern how the survey was run, not whether the sample represents the population.
Question 2
Difficulty: medium≈ 2 min
Inspectors tested 12 apples from the top layer of a crate and found them all fresh. The inspector concludes that every apple in the crate is fresh.
Which one of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the conclusion?
AA. Apples at the top of a crate are less likely to be bruised or spoiled than those underneath.
BB. The crate was packed by a supplier that discards any apple showing even the slightest bruise or spot.
CC. The crate was packed the day before the inspection and kept in a cool storeroom overnight.
DD. Twelve apples is more than the number that inspectors usually test from a single crate.
EE. The apples in the crate are of a variety that is known to keep well for several weeks.
Show answer and explanation
Correct answer: A. Apples at the top of a crate are less likely to be bruised or spoiled than those underneath.
Explanation
Showing that the group sampled differs systematically from the larger group attacks the generalization: apples at the top of a crate are less likely to be bruised or spoiled than those underneath. The option reporting independent data that match the result would strengthen the conclusion, and the others are details that do not affect representativeness.
Question 3
Difficulty: hard≈ 2 min
Archaeologists have concluded that the coastal village was abandoned because of a prolonged drought. They point out that layers of pollen in a nearby lake show a steep decline in grasses and cereals during the period in which the village was abandoned, and that the village's wells were deepened twice shortly before its last occupation.
Which one of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the archaeologists' reasoning?
AA. Other villages in the region survived the same period.
BB. The wells were dug by the earliest inhabitants of the village.
CC. The decline in grass and cereal pollen began only after the village had been abandoned.
DD. Drought-resistant crops were available to the villagers.
EE. Coastal villages are abandoned for many different reasons.
Show answer and explanation
Correct answer: C. The decline in grass and cereal pollen began only after the village had been abandoned.
Explanation
If the pollen decline began after the abandonment, the drought it indicates cannot have caused the village to be abandoned, which undercuts the main evidence. The survival of other villages, the age of the wells and the availability of other crops are compatible with a drought at this village, and the last option is too general to attack this argument.