Pregunta 1
Passage II — Social Science: two passages about free public transit (original texts)
Passage A
When a city removes fares from its buses, ridership almost always rises, sometimes sharply. In the first year after one midsize European city made its buses free, the number of trips grew by more than a third. Supporters see this as proof that fares keep people off public transit and that removing them can ease traffic and cut pollution.
The argument has a simple appeal. A fare is a small but constant reminder that every trip costs money, and for households with little income, that reminder can decide whether a parent takes a job across town or a teenager goes to an after-school program. Free transit, in this view, is less a transportation policy than a way of widening the range of places people can afford to reach.
There are practical benefits as well. Collecting fares is expensive: machines must be bought and repaired, cash must be counted and guarded, and drivers lose time at every stop as passengers search for change. In some small systems, fares bring in barely more money than it costs to collect them. Removing fares also lets passengers board through every door, which shortens stops and makes buses faster for everyone.
Critics sometimes object that free buses will be crowded with people who would otherwise have walked. But a trip that replaces a walk still carries a person somewhere they wanted to go. Measured by how many people can reach work, school, and medical care, free transit succeeds.
Passage B
The rise in ridership after fares are removed is real, but it is worth asking where the new riders come from. Studies of several fare-free programs have found that many of the added trips were made by people who previously walked or rode bicycles, not by people who previously drove. Traffic and pollution, the problems free transit is often promised to solve, barely changed.
This matters because fares, though unpopular, pay for a share of the service. In many large systems they cover a quarter or more of operating costs. When that money disappears, it must be replaced by taxes, or else the system must cut service. And service, more than price, is what most riders say they care about. A bus that is free but comes every forty minutes is less useful to a worker than one that costs a little and comes every ten.
None of this means that fares should be high or that low-income riders should be left to struggle. Many cities offer reduced fares to students, older adults, and people with low incomes, which helps those who most need it without giving up revenue from those who can pay. The money that a city would spend replacing all fare revenue could instead pay for more frequent buses, new routes, and better shelters.
Free transit is a generous idea. But generosity in transportation is measured less by what a ride costs than by whether the bus shows up.
Both passages agree that removing fares:
- A. increases the number of trips taken on public transit.
- B. reduces traffic and pollution.
- C. should be paid for with higher taxes.
- D. is the best way to help low-income riders.
Ver respuesta y explicación
Respuesta correcta: A. increases the number of trips taken on public transit.
Explicación
Passage A says ridership “almost always rises,” and Passage B begins by granting that “the rise in ridership after fares are removed is real.”
Passage B denies that traffic and pollution fall, neither passage endorses higher taxes, and Passage B favors reduced fares instead.