Negate the option: if the argument collapses, it is needed.
Pièges fréquents
An option that helps but is not required.
Exemples de questions
Essayez de répondre avant d'ouvrir le corrigé. Les questions sont dans la langue de l'examen.
Question 1
Difficulté: moyenne≈ 1 min
If the band signs with the label, then it records in a studio. Therefore, if the band signs with the label, then it postpones its tour.
The conclusion of the argument is properly drawn if which one of the following is assumed?
AA. If the band postpones its tour, then it records in a studio.
BB. If the band does not sign with the label, then it does not record in a studio.
CC. If the band records in a studio, then it postpones its tour.
DD. The band signs with the label.
EE. If the band postpones its tour, then it signs with the label.
Voir la réponse et l'explication
Bonne réponse: C. If the band records in a studio, then it postpones its tour.
Explication
To link the first condition to the third, the argument needs the missing step from the second to the third. The reversed conditional (from the third back to the second) does not help, because conditionals do not run backward.
Question 2
Difficulté: moyenne≈ 1 min
If the lab wins the contract, then it buys the new scanner. Therefore, if the lab wins the contract, then it expands its night shift.
The conclusion of the argument is properly drawn if which one of the following is assumed?
AA. If the lab expands its night shift, then it buys the new scanner.
BB. If the lab does not win the contract, then it does not buy the new scanner.
CC. The lab wins the contract.
DD. If the lab buys the new scanner, then it expands its night shift.
EE. If the lab expands its night shift, then it wins the contract.
Voir la réponse et l'explication
Bonne réponse: D. If the lab buys the new scanner, then it expands its night shift.
Explication
To link the first condition to the third, the argument needs the missing step from the second to the third. The reversed conditional (from the third back to the second) does not help, because conditionals do not run backward.
Question 3
Difficulté: difficile≈ 1 min
Nutritionist: People who switch from sugary drinks to water usually lose weight within a few months. The new tax on sugary drinks will lead many people in the city to replace sugary drinks with water. So the tax will help many people in the city lose weight.
The nutritionist's argument requires the assumption that
AA. everyone who switches from sugary drinks to water because of the tax will lose a noticeable amount of weight within a few months
BB. people who switch to water because of a tax are not much less likely to lose weight than others who switch
CC. the tax will raise more money for the city each year than it costs the city to collect
DD. water costs less than any of the sugary drinks that are sold in shops in the city
EE. most of the people in the city who regularly drink sugary drinks are overweight
Voir la réponse et l'explication
Bonne réponse: B. people who switch to water because of a tax are not much less likely to lose weight than others who switch
Explication
The evidence concerns people who switch in general; the conclusion concerns people who switch because of the tax. If those people were much less likely to lose weight (for example, because they replace the sugar with snacks), the evidence would not carry over. The 'everyone' option is far stronger than the argument needs, and cost or the weight of current drinkers is irrelevant.