examARnow Guides

LSAT · Logical Reasoning · Question types

Flaw

What error does the reasoning make?

LSAT (Law School Admission Test)Logical ReasoningPoids: 100 %
S'entraîner : Flaw37 questions originales pour cette compétence, corrigées immédiatement.

L'essentiel

Méthode pas à pas

Pièges fréquents

Exemples de questions

Essayez de répondre avant d'ouvrir le corrigé. Les questions sont dans la langue de l'examen.

Question 1

Difficulté: facile≈ 1 min

Anyone with a library card can borrow e-books. Tom borrowed an e-book. Therefore, Tom must have a library card.

The reasoning in the argument is flawed because it

  1. A. treats a condition that is sufficient for an outcome as though it were necessary for it
  2. B. assumes that what is true of each member of a group must be true of the group as a whole
  3. C. attacks the person making a claim rather than the claim itself
  4. D. shifts the meaning of a key term from one part of the argument to another
  5. E. presents two options as exhaustive when other options exist
Voir la réponse et l'explication

Bonne réponse: A. treats a condition that is sufficient for an outcome as though it were necessary for it

Explication

The first sentence gives a sufficient condition for an outcome, not the only way to get that outcome. The argument treats the outcome (tom borrowed an e-book) as proof that the condition occurred.

Question 2

Difficulté: moyenne≈ 2 min

If the farm passes inspection, then it ships to the export market. The farm ships to the export market. Therefore, the farm passes inspection.

The reasoning above is flawed because it

  1. A. assumes that what is true of a group as a whole must be true of each member of the group
  2. B. treats a condition that is sufficient for an outcome as though it were necessary for it
  3. C. relies on the opinion of a source without establishing that the source has relevant expertise
  4. D. mistakes a correlation between two things for evidence that one causes the other
  5. E. uses its conclusion as one of its own premises
Voir la réponse et l'explication

Bonne réponse: B. treats a condition that is sufficient for an outcome as though it were necessary for it

Explication

Knowing that the result occurred (the farm ships to the export market) does not show that the sufficient condition occurred (the farm passes inspection), because the result could have happened for another reason. This is the error of affirming the consequent.

Question 3

Difficulté: difficile≈ 1 min

Each of the twelve paintings in the new exhibition was chosen by the curator because it is an outstanding example of its own style. Therefore, the exhibition as a whole is certain to be an outstanding example of curation.

The reasoning in the argument is flawed in that it

  1. A. presumes that what is true of a whole collection must also be true of each of the items in it
  2. B. presumes that a whole must have a quality simply because each of its parts has that quality
  3. C. relies on the judgment of a curator whose expertise has not been established
  4. D. fails to explain what makes a painting an outstanding example of its style
  5. E. concludes that the paintings are outstanding merely because they were chosen
Voir la réponse et l'explication

Bonne réponse: B. presumes that a whole must have a quality simply because each of its parts has that quality

Explication

Twelve outstanding paintings could still make a poorly curated exhibition (badly arranged, with no coherent theme). The argument moves from the parts to the whole. The reverse error (whole to parts) is the trap, and the argument does not depend on the curator's expertise: it takes the paintings' quality as given.

Continuer à s'entraîner

S'entraîner : Flaw37 questions originales pour cette compétence, corrigées immédiatement.

Autres compétences de Logical Reasoning

Format complet de l'examen LSAT · Tous les guides