Describe what the argument does, not what it says.
Méthode pas à pas
Find the conclusion and premises before reading the options.
Pièges fréquents
Options that overstate (never, any) or describe another argument.
Exemples de questions
Essayez de répondre avant d'ouvrir le corrigé. Les questions sont dans la langue de l'examen.
Question 1
Difficulté: moyenne≈ 2 min
Mayor: Suppose the new dam had weakened the riverbank. Then inspectors would have found cracks in the retaining wall during this spring's flood. They found none. So the dam has not weakened the riverbank.
The mayor's argument proceeds by
AA. showing that a result expected if a hypothesis were true was not observed, and concluding that the hypothesis is false
BB. citing a case in which the dam did weaken a riverbank
CC. arguing that cracks in a retaining wall are unrelated to the dam
DD. establishing that the riverbank was weak before the dam was built
EE. applying a general rule about dams to a particular dam
Voir la réponse et l'explication
Bonne réponse: A. showing that a result expected if a hypothesis were true was not observed, and concluding that the hypothesis is false
Explication
The mayor assumes a hypothesis (the dam weakened the bank), derives a predicted observation (cracks), notes that it was not seen and rejects the hypothesis. The argument does not cite another dam, deny the link between cracks and the dam, discuss the bank's earlier condition or apply a general rule.
Question 2
Difficulté: moyenne≈ 1 min
Critic: Some people complain that the new bridge design is ugly. But beauty is not the purpose of a bridge. A bridge exists to carry traffic safely, and this design does that better than any alternative. So the complaint about the design's appearance is beside the point.
The critic responds to the objection by
AA. denying the facts on which the objection is based
BB. arguing that the feature objected to is irrelevant to the purpose of the thing being judged
CC. suggesting that the people who object are biased
DD. offering a counterexample to a general claim about bridges
EE. citing an authority who disagrees with the objectors
Voir la réponse et l'explication
Bonne réponse: B. arguing that the feature objected to is irrelevant to the purpose of the thing being judged
Explication
The critic accepts that the bridge may be ugly and argues that appearance does not matter for a bridge's purpose, which is to carry traffic safely. No facts are denied, no bias is alleged, no counterexample is offered and no authority is cited.
Question 3
Difficulté: moyenne≈ 2 min
Mia: You say the city should ban cars from the old town because cars cause accidents. By that reasoning you should also want to ban bicycles, since bicycles cause accidents too. Ken: Not at all. Cars in the old town have caused several serious injuries every year, while bicycles have caused only minor scrapes.
Ken responds to Mia by
AA. denying that cars cause accidents in the old town
BB. accepting Mia's principle and then showing that it has an absurd consequence
CC. pointing out a difference between the two cases that is relevant to the principle Mia invokes
DD. claiming that Mia's position is inconsistent with her earlier statements
EE. showing that bicycles are safer than any other form of transport
Voir la réponse et l'explication
Bonne réponse: C. pointing out a difference between the two cases that is relevant to the principle Mia invokes
Explication
Mia treats cars and bicycles alike because both cause accidents. Ken answers that the accidents differ in seriousness, a difference that matters for the reason (preventing accidents) behind the ban. He does not deny that cars cause accidents, nor attack Mia's earlier statements, and he compares bicycles only with cars in the old town.