examARnow Guides

GMAT · Verbal · Critical Reasoning

Roles of statements

What roles two highlighted statements play.

GMAT Focus EditionVerbal ReasoningWeight: ≈50 %
Practise Roles of statements for free15 original questions for this skill, marked instantly.

Key points

Step-by-step strategy

Common traps

Sample questions

Try to answer before opening the solution.

Question 1

Difficulty: easy≈ 2 min

A restaurant owner says that his new menu has attracted more diners. The number of diners per night rose by a fifth after the new menu was introduced. His accountant points out that a large conference was held in the neighborhood that month, so the extra diners may simply be conference participants. The owner replies that the numbers stayed high after the conference ended.

The two boldface portions play which of the following roles?

  1. A. The first is the conclusion the owner draws; the second is evidence the accountant offers in support of that conclusion.
  2. B. The first is evidence offered in support of the owner's claim; the second is the main conclusion that the passage as a whole supports.
  3. C. The first is evidence offered in support of the owner's claim; the second is an alternative explanation for that evidence.
  4. D. The first is a consideration the accountant uses to challenge the owner's claim; the second is the owner's reply to it.
  5. E. The first is a prediction made by the owner; the second is a finding that confirms that prediction.
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: C. The first is evidence offered in support of the owner's claim; the second is an alternative explanation for that evidence.

Explanation

The first boldface is evidence for the owner's claim; the second offers a different explanation for that evidence. The conclusion is that the menu attracted diners.

Question 2

Difficulty: medium≈ 2 min

A farmer argues that rotating crops improves yields. Her wheat harvest rose by a tenth after she began alternating wheat with beans. An agricultural advisor points out that rainfall was above normal that year, so the rain may account for the better harvest. The farmer replies that her neighbors, who did not rotate crops, saw no increase.

The two boldface portions play which of the following roles?

  1. A. The first is evidence for the farmer's claim; the second is the farmer's own reply to the advisor's objection.
  2. B. The first is the farmer's conclusion; the second is an objection to it.
  3. C. The first is evidence for the farmer's claim; the second is an alternative explanation for that evidence.
  4. D. The first is an objection; the second is the reply to it.
  5. E. The first is a prediction; the second restates it.
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: C. The first is evidence for the farmer's claim; the second is an alternative explanation for that evidence.

Explanation

The first boldface is evidence for the farmer's claim; the second, from the advisor, offers a different explanation for it. The farmer's reply is the point about her neighbors, and her conclusion is that rotation improves yields.

Question 3

Difficulty: hard≈ 2 min

A real estate analyst argues that coastal home prices will fall because insurance costs are climbing. Premiums on coastal homes have doubled in five years. Some homeowners respond that demand remains strong. The analyst replies that strong demand today would not stop prices from falling once buyers take higher insurance costs into account.

The two boldface portions play which of the following roles?

  1. A. The first is evidence supporting the analyst's position; the second is the analyst's answer to an objection to that position.
  2. B. The first is evidence supporting the analyst's position; the second is the homeowners' objection, which the analyst then goes on to answer.
  3. C. The first is the analyst's conclusion; the second is a premise supporting it.
  4. D. The first is an objection to the analyst's argument; the second is a restatement of that objection.
  5. E. The first is a statement the homeowners dispute; the second is a statement they accept.
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: A. The first is evidence supporting the analyst's position; the second is the analyst's answer to an objection to that position.

Explanation

The doubling of premiums is evidence for the analyst's claim. The second boldface is the analyst's own answer to the homeowners' objection about demand, not the objection itself. The conclusion is that prices will fall.

Keep practising

Practise Roles of statements for free15 original questions for this skill, marked instantly.

Other Verbal skills

Full GMAT format · All guides