examARnow Guides

GMAT · Verbal · Critical Reasoning

Evaluate

What information would help judge the argument.

GMAT Focus EditionVerbal ReasoningWeight: ≈50 %
Practise Evaluate for free15 original questions for this skill, marked instantly.

Key points

Step-by-step strategy

Common traps

Sample questions

Try to answer before opening the solution.

Question 1

Difficulty: easy≈ 2 min

A restaurant critic argues that a new restaurant must be excellent, since it is always crowded on weekends.

Which of the following would be most useful to know in evaluating the critic's argument?

  1. A. How many tables the restaurant has, and how long diners usually have to wait for a table on a busy Saturday evening.
  2. B. Whether the restaurant serves breakfast.
  3. C. What the restaurant's name means.
  4. D. Whether the restaurant is crowded because of the quality of its food or because of its location or low prices.
  5. E. Who designed the restaurant's interior.
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: D. Whether the restaurant is crowded because of the quality of its food or because of its location or low prices.

Explanation

The critic infers quality from crowds; learning what draws the crowd tests that link. The other facts are irrelevant to the inference.

Question 2

Difficulty: medium≈ 2 min

A farmer argues that his switch to a new fertilizer improved his crop yield, because his yield per hectare was higher this year than last year.

Which of the following would be most useful to know in evaluating the farmer's argument?

  1. A. Whether the new fertilizer costs more per hectare than the fertilizer the farmer used before.
  2. B. Whether the farmer plans to use the new fertilizer again next year.
  3. C. Whether weather conditions this year were better for the crop than last year.
  4. D. Where the fertilizer is manufactured.
  5. E. How many hectares the farmer owns.
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: C. Whether weather conditions this year were better for the crop than last year.

Explanation

If the weather was better this year, the higher yield may not be due to the fertilizer. Knowing the weather helps decide whether to credit the fertilizer.

Question 3

Difficulty: hard≈ 2 min

A transport authority argues that raising bus fares will increase its total revenue, since the cost of running each bus is rising.

Which of the following would be most useful to know in evaluating the authority's argument?

  1. A. How many riders would stop taking buses if fares rose, and whether that loss outweighs the gain from those who stay.
  2. B. How quickly the cost of running each bus is rising, and whether fuel or drivers' wages account for most of the rise.
  3. C. How many buses the authority owns.
  4. D. What the average age of the buses is.
  5. E. Whether drivers are paid by the hour.
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: A. How many riders would stop taking buses if fares rose, and whether that loss outweighs the gain from those who stay.

Explanation

Revenue depends on how many riders leave versus how much more the remaining riders pay. Rising costs explain the motive but say nothing about revenue.

Keep practising

Practise Evaluate for free15 original questions for this skill, marked instantly.

Other Verbal skills

Full GMAT format · All guides