examARnow Guides

GMAT · Verbal · Critical Reasoning

Resolve a paradox

What reconciles two facts that seem to clash.

GMAT Focus EditionVerbal ReasoningWeight: ≈50 %
Practise Resolve a paradox for free23 original questions for this skill, marked instantly.

Key points

Step-by-step strategy

Common traps

Sample questions

Try to answer before opening the solution.

Question 1

Difficulty: easy≈ 2 min

A study of two neighboring lakes found that Lake A, which has more fish than Lake B, nevertheless has fewer fishing boats on the water at any one time.

Which of the following, if true, most helps to explain the difference?

  1. A. The fish in Lake A are, on average, larger and more prized by anglers than those in Lake B.
  2. B. Lake B is closed to fishing for several months of the year to protect spawning fish.
  3. C. Lake A is very difficult to reach by road, and few anglers know of it.
  4. D. Fishing licenses cost the same for both lakes and are sold at the same local shops.
  5. E. Anglers who fish Lake A report catching more fish per hour than anglers on Lake B do.
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: C. Lake A is very difficult to reach by road, and few anglers know of it.

Explanation

Fewer boats despite more fish needs a reason anglers do not use Lake A: access or awareness. Larger fish, higher catch rates, or closures on Lake B would make Lake A more attractive and deepen the puzzle, and identical licenses change nothing.

Question 2

Difficulty: medium≈ 2 min

A gym noticed that member attendance dropped during the months when it offered free guest passes, even though the passes were popular.

Which of the following would best explain this?

  1. A. Guests crowded the gym at peak hours, and regular members stayed away to avoid the crowds.
  2. B. Many guests who used the passes were members' friends who later signed up for memberships of their own.
  3. C. Guest passes were valid for one week and could be used only at the main location.
  4. D. The gym has several locations, and attendance is counted separately at each one.
  5. E. Members who brought guests tended to visit the gym more often than members who did not.
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: A. Guests crowded the gym at peak hours, and regular members stayed away to avoid the crowds.

Explanation

A side effect of the passes that discourages members explains the drop. New sign-ups and members visiting more with guests would predict higher attendance, and pass rules or counting methods do not link the passes to fewer member visits.

Question 3

Difficulty: hard≈ 2 min

A sports league introduced bigger helmets to reduce concussions. In the following season the number of reported concussions rose.

Which of the following, if true, most helps to explain the rise?

  1. A. The league made players pay for the new helmets, and many complained about the cost.
  2. B. Players and coaches became more aware of concussions and began reporting mild cases they once ignored.
  3. C. The league's season had the same length and number of games as in previous years.
  4. D. Players said the bigger helmets felt more comfortable and fit better than the old ones.
  5. E. Concussions are less common in most other contact sports than in this one.
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: B. Players and coaches became more aware of concussions and began reporting mild cases they once ignored.

Explanation

Better reporting can raise the count without more injuries; it reconciles the helmet's purpose with the data. Cost, comfort, and an unchanged season do not account for a rise.

Keep practising

Practise Resolve a paradox for free23 original questions for this skill, marked instantly.

Other Verbal skills

Full GMAT format · All guides